An investigation into the relevance of flexibility- and interoperability requirements for implementation processes for workflow-management-applications
Abstract
Flexibility and Interoperability have become important characteristics for organisations and their business processes. The need to control flexible business processes within an organisation’s boundaries and between organisations imposes major requirements on a company’s process control capabilities. Workflow Management Systems (WFMS) try to fulfil these requirements by offering respective product features. Evidence suggests that the achievement of flexible business processes and an inter-organisational process control is also influenced by implementation processes for Workflow Management Applications (WFMA). [A WFMA comprises the WFMS and "all WFMS specific data with regard to one or more business processes" [VER01]]. The impact of a WFMA implementation methodology on the fulfilment of these requirements is the research scope of the project. The thesis provides knowledge in the following areas: 1. Review of the relationship between workflow management and the claim for process flexibility respectively -interoperability. 2. Definition of a research-/evaluation framework for workflow projects. This framework is composed of all relevant research variables that have been identified for the thesis. 3. Empirical survey of relevant workflow-project objectives and their priority in the context of process flexibility and –interoperability. 4. Empirical survey of the objectives’ achievement. 5. Empirical survey of methodologies / activities that have been applied within workflow projects. 6. Derivation of the project methodologies’ effectiveness in terms of the impact that applied activities had on project objectives. 7. Evaluation of existing workflow life-cycle models in accordance with the research framework. 8. Identification of basic improvements for workflow implementation processes with respect to the achievement of flexible and interoperable business processes. The first part of the thesis argues the relevance of the subject. Afterwards research variables that constitute the evaluation framework for WFMA implementation processes are stepwise identified and defined. An empirical study then proves the variables’ effectiveness for the achievement of process flexibility and –interoperability within the WFMA implementation process. After this the framework is applied to evaluate chosen WFMA implementation methodologies. Identified weaknesses and effective methodological aspects are utilised to develop generic methodological improvements. These improvements are later validated by means of a case study and interviews with workflow experts.Publisher
University of WolverhamptonType
Thesis or dissertationLanguage
enCollections
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
An Investigation into quality assurance of the Open Source Software Development modelThe Open Source Software Development (OSSD) model has launched products in rapid succession and with high quality, without following traditional quality practices of accepted software development models (Raymond 1999). Some OSSD projects challenge established quality assurance approaches, claiming to be successful through partial contrary techniques of standard software development. However, empirical studies of quality assurance practices for Open Source Software (OSS) are rare (Glass 2001). Therefore, further research is required to evaluate the quality assurance processes and methods within the OSSD model. The aim of this research is to improve the understanding of quality assurance practices under the OSSD model. The OSSD model is characterised by a collaborative, distributed development approach with public communication, free participation, free entry to the project for newcomers and unlimited access to the source code. The research examines applied quality assurance practices from a process view rather than from a product view. The research follows ideographic and nomothetic methodologies and adopts an antipositivist epistemological approach. An empirical research of applied quality assurance practices in OSS projects is conducted through the literature research. The survey research method is used to gain empirical evidence about applied practices. The findings are used to validate the theoretical knowledge and to obtain further expertise about practical approaches. The findings contribute to the development of a quality assurance framework for standard OSSD approaches. The result is an appropriate quality model with metrics that the requirements of the OSSD support. An ideographic approach with case studies is used to extend the body of knowledge and to assess the feasibility and applicability of the quality assurance framework. In conclusion, the study provides further understanding of the applied quality assurance processes under the OSSD model and shows how a quality assurance framework can support the development processes with guidelines and measurements.
-
Practical incremental application of process improvement, optimisation and manufacturing theories in small to medium enterprises (SMEs)Due to rapidly changing and highly competitive nature of today’s market place, manufacturing companies now recognise that survival and profitability are functions of continuous improvement. High quality and reliable products must be produced and delivered at lower cost than the competition. This has led to adoption of a range of time and quality based competitive paradigm/programmes such as Zero Defects, Lean Manufacturing, Six Sigma, JIT, SMED, etc. Evidence from many large Japanese companies and others large companies in the EU and USA showed that these programmes contribute substantial benefits. However, in the case of SMEs, proofs of such successes are scant. Factors such as lack of resources, knowledge and culture are some of the factors shown to be militating against SMEs. By extension, it can also be argued that such factors are the main grounds why SMEs have problems adopting and implementing improvement programmes because improvement programmes require time, money and knowledge. This research focused on how to evaluate and assist SMEs to achieve the most out of existing resources, and hence become more competitive, using a case study company as an implementation and validation platform. A framework for achieving process improvement despite limited resources and resistance to change was demonstrated utilising widely available and often inexpensive tools. The main outcomes of this study include a £4 per unit cost reduction and more than 54% increase in capacity, and actual increase in sales of those products affected by the project of £868000. Other outcomes include productivity increases and stabilisation of lead times, knowledge-capture, and development of in-house MRP spread sheet and standard times to help with accurate product costing, culture change, reduced space requirement and production process layout. Most significantly the study established a new empirical stage on which others can build upon and understand how to implement process improvement in SMEs. Specifically, sensitivity to an organisation’s environment and its politics as essential ingredients, must accompany World Class Manufacturing techniques.
